running of brushless motor ... plz help...

Started by pankaj, February 04, 2010, 01:30:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

pankaj

 :help:i have just purchased 4 brushless motors and 4 ESCs to make a quadrotor heli. ???
i have a 4 channel tranceiver, so can i put all the 4 ESCs signal plug(the three pin wire  :-X) into the receiver. :banghead:

yea i know question is childish but plz help ...(upload images if possible :salute:) .thanks in advance.
:help:
image is below..

anwar

#1
Receiver power should be provided by only one of the ESCs, so disconnect the middle wire from the 3 wire cables from other three ESCs. 
Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

pankaj

#2
my one channel of tranceiver is not working so which 4 chanel tranceiver should i buy .

{Model Cells KV Prop RPM Current Thrust                 brushless motor

CF2822 3S 950 10X5 6800 10A 685g/1.4lb.}

and 18 amps ESC. purchased from rcdhamaka.com....

thanks for the help
btw i m from NIT Calicut kerala.

anwar

What transmitter and receiver are you using ?  That information is a must before people can recommend which receiver  to buy.

Also, how did you confirm that one of the channels is indeed not working ?
Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

pankaj

 i m not using any :'(,i just got one and my friend(to whom it belongs) told me that 3 channels are working only...
so i m planning to buy a new one ,nyway i have to buy a new one later....kindly suggest . thanks.


anwar

The issue is that the type of receiver is intimately related to the type of transmitter. 

So if are you going to use a new receiver with your friend's existing transmitter, then please let us know that brand and model that transmitter is.

Or, if your intention is to get a completely new pair (transmitter and receiver), then please clarify it.
Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

pankaj

#6
thank you everyone for your support ...

very active community....must say ...hats off

pankaj

Quote from: anwar on February 04, 2010, 01:32:46 AM
Receiver power should be provided by only one of the ESCs, so disconnect the middle wire from the 3 wire cables from other three ESCs. 

is middle wire same in all ESCs coz i m using EMAX  esc 18 a..

pankaj

 (:|~any other tips regarding quad rotor most welcomed.. {:)}

pankaj

#9
Quote
Channels : The number of distinct/individual controls you can remotely operate. They can be motor / servo / lights etc.

You can control 4 distinct items with a four channel radio system; typically one motor and 3 servos.

this is a quote of anwar sir on another question....

my question is that can't we control 4 brushless motors from a 4 channel radio system.....(or is it one brushless motor and 3 servos).. ???

anwar

The answer is in my quote itself. Each channel can control one item. *Typically* it is one motor and 3 servos, but that is only the common case.  It can be a mix of motors, servos, lights etc; including only/multiple motors.
Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

rcforall

You cannot run 4 motors like 4 servos of a plane .
Quad needs mixing .
I came across this some time back , but the motors are brushed motors :
http://www.rcindia.org/self-designed-diy-and-college-projects/quad-rotor/

Sai
www.zuppa.io : vehicle telematics, ADAS, IoT , Drones

anwar

I did not get into the specifics of the "quad design" itself.  But technically, a receiver can very well throttle control 4 motors.  What Sai is trying to say is that just connecting them that way will NOT give you a flying quad-rotor.
Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

rcforall

Your  right Anwar  a Servo is also a motor  hence running motors per say is not the problem the issue is to get a controllable air craft
www.zuppa.io : vehicle telematics, ADAS, IoT , Drones

Anjan

I agree.
Just connecting 4 motors to a single throttle will not give a controllable quadrotor.
The motor control must be mixed to get a stable flight.
Then the must be a control loop to stabilize the quad in flight ,hover and transition from hover to flight n vice versa.

pankaj

  yes i want both transmitter and receiver.....
72mhz or 2.4 ghz ..i dont care  .....all i want is 100 to 300 meters distance of operation...
and not to mention ....cost must be comparitively less ...

thanks "anwar" sir for your help
. :help:is it necessary to put a gyro on my quadcopter or can i go along without a gyro...
(i dont want a gyro personally )

vinay

Since the signals from all the channels are same, Using 2 Gyros, 1 each for any 2 adjacent motors should automaticaly throttle control and get a stable hover. Better use HH mode  ;) But expensive on the other hand. These gyros should take care of any changes in wind etc. Each gyros cost 700 bucks though, but can be reused in any other planes/Helis in the future. Just my suggestion ;D.

anwar

#17
Product selection is entirely your thing, as you alone know your constraints (budget,features etc) ;) 

There was one mentioned here from Sai/RCForAll.

About the gyro part, I never really looked into quad designs in any depth, so it would take me some good reading up to answer this question.  It is probably the same as you doing it :)

Plus, there is quite some discussion on this forum itself.
Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

pankaj

#18
can anybody help me selecting a Tx and Rx(4 channel) for 4 brushless motors :banghead:

heard that rcforall(sai sir) is providing a 4 channel tranciever(tx and rx) in 2700rs.

any suggestions....

vinay

Budget? AFAIK the cheapest useful ones is the 2.4 Ghz from Sai. Also if possible dont buy just a 4 ch one, buy the 6ch ones. You may need another 2 spare channels in case you want to put a servo in there or build a plane with flaps. I thought you already had a TX/RX. ???

pankaj

#20
 :discuss: :discuss: i am planning to manually wirelessly control all the 4 motor via 4 channels.is a gyro necessary??

for tx and rx what about this ....
http://www.hobbycity.com/hobbycity/store/uh_viewItem.asp?idProduct=8337&Product_Name=Hobby_King_2.4Ghz_4Ch_Tx_&_Rx_(Mode_1)

sound like cheaper than rcforall...
not sure about quality..

Anjan

dnt know if its possible to control 4 motors manually,
Without any mixing n all.
A small mistake can bring down the whole thing.
Flight stabilization is a issue
where u may have to adjust speed constantly.

anwar

#22
1. Ordering radio from outside :  Please read up on the issues people have been with this option.  It would entirely depend on your luck whether it reaches you (with or without customs duty), or gets held by customs as a banned item.

2. Flying a heli where only one control needs to be stabilized (the tail) without a gyro is practically impossible even for the best RC heli pilots.  A quad rotor would have much more inherent instability. So you can imagine what kind of a task you are signing up for :( 

I say this with brotherly affection... that it looks like you have quite a bit of homework to do on what you are trying to do, and there is no short-cut except to read (and then read some more) !
Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

vinay

Also before you choose on any radio, see if it supports all the mixing that is requrired for this project and FUTURE.

For example, before buying a radio, I always thought I would never fly Helis as I didnt like them. But I still went ahead and brought a radio that supported Helis well. And now my first RC toy is a Heli :giggle: and I still don't own a plane yet.

pankaj

alright ....everybody thanks .. :salute:

here are all the helps recieved...

1. it is almost impossible to hover a quad without gyro due to stability issues.(anwar sir)...................yes i got it with brotherly affection :-[
2. mixing diagram for quadrotor (rcforall).....................will be aproaching you for mixers and gyros shortly. {:)}
3. buy a 6 ch tx rx as you may need one spare channel(vinay)............i will try if my budget allows.. :-\