Review - HK 450 PRO TT - Torque tube version

Started by anwar, April 23, 2010, 04:52:46 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

anwar

Finally took some time off to build the HK 450 PRO heli (Torque Tube version).  It has been several weeks since I got the kit, but today was the day !

It took about 8 hours (including the time to pull out the electronics from another 450 heli) in total.  Test hovered it outside the house, full forward flight test and moving to mild 3D will be at the field.

Some points to note so far.....

1.  Even though many parts come preassembled, you really have to take it apart and build it back. There is hardly any thread-lock on the screws that go into metal, and zero grease on the thrust bearings. 

2.  To make matters worse, some of the screws in the head are not hex ones, they are regular ones.  There seems to be some threadlock on these non-hex ones, making then difficult to remove.

4.  The non-hex screws are easy to strip, so be careful when you build them.

5.  Even though I had many parts, I wanted to see what the default setup will do, so full flights and more testing will be done then.  Not sure if the supplied blades can in handle pitch pump movements, anyways will try them out.

Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

vinay

Quote from: anwar on April 23, 2010, 04:52:46 AM
2.  To make matters worse, some of the screws in the head are not hex ones, they are regular ones.  There seems to be some threadlock on these non-hex ones, making then difficult to remove.

4.  The non-hex screws are easy to strip, so be careful when you build them.

Anwar, its really bad to know that the screws in the head are not Hex! Seriously!

As you pointed out the regular philip screws really strip easily on my V2. Infact, I have decided I will never use those screws for the second time after a crash.

But really cant complain at that price! You wont even get an Align head for that price of the Entire HK PRO TT heli. But still what you pay is what you get. BTW with good electronics of your previous heli, hope this flies well.

BTW dont forget to make a video of your 3D flight. Waiting for it  (:|~.

What pinion and Head speeds? Also was there vibrations in the tail. I read that many users are experiencing this.

Can you post some more pics of the wiring?

anwar

About the screws on the head, most of them are hex.  But the few that are not, are all problematic.

Flew on the field this morning.  Have some video, but it was a very hazy day, not sure how the footage will look like.  Will post later.

For 3D I ran a straight 100s curve on a 13T pinion.  Need to confirm the head-speed.
Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

anwar

Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

vinay


anwar

Depends on what "good" is !   If you ask me, I would say "Not really".  That is a different class. You will realize when you fly one ;)

Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

vinay

Ya true, I just judged from the video. I havent even seen a 600 size fly in front of my eyes.

vinay

Got mine today, Post woman called me up and said - the box is too big, can you collect it? Went to the Post office and collected it. The box was declared at 58 USD. No customs.  Reached me in 10 days FLAT after booking. Havent opned the box yet. Will post pics once I reach home.

I wont be opening a separate build threads as the products are same.

Electronics:

Henge 933 cyclics.
Futaba gy401 or Spartan Quark
S9257 tail.
Turnigy nanotechs 90 c battery.
Either Super brain or Castle Ice 75 lite if it reaches me first. Will run on governor for sure.
2836 700 Watts 3700 kv turnigy monster motor  :giggle: on 12/13 t

replacements:
Align feathering shaft - rest would be stock.
TIG 325 MM Carbon fiber blades from HC.

ujjwaana

Hola! Tell Auntie to prepare some snacks for me.. I would be dropping at your place today to see this beauty and pick my other stuff.
Futaba 8FG Super | HK-450v2 | FA-22 Raptor |AXN Floater-Jet | FunJet | Black Horse Edge 540 | Amp Master 015 | 2.3M Big Brother

vinay

Mom went to native today, so bad luck for u  ;) BTW, if u want, I have ur stuff at office, in case u want to collect. If you want to come to my place, land by 830 PM.

vinay

Can I use the Align original Umbrella gears and tail shaft here? I was about to order some spares from align so...

anwar

Umbrella gears ?  If you mean torque tube gears, then yes.  The torque tube is also compatible.
Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

vinay

Ya, ordering umbrella gears and TTubes. Dont know if HK quality supports high HS.

vinay

Some more pics and issues:

1)Main gear unfixable! No matter what I played with the 1 way bearing  >:D

2)Replaced with V2 gear. This is why u need spares  :bow:

3)450 tt Motor mount wont take standard HK screws  :giggle: Had to file it.

4)JASON SAYS - Our helis are built with TIGHT TOLERANCES. It looks like the head had a little OVER TIGHT TOLERANCE!  :giggle:  Anwar bayya, dont know how u fixed this but I had to remove the trust bearing for the screws to be a tight fit, THAT TOO With the Align orginal collar which is thinner than the HK ones. Other wise it was clicking.

FIX - Just used more blue loctite and tightened the screw till the Feathering shaft rotated. Did the same thing on the other end. I ofcourse put the T bearing back  ;)

UPDATE: The trust bearings had hex screws and not Philips as Anwar received.

vinay

HK 450 V2 vs PRO

1)The head size are almost the same regardless of the extra size feathering shaft of the PRO. I dont understand why people say pro flies better!  :headscratch:

The shaft of the pro is longer but the grips are shorter making it finally small. The only + point is that since the links are larger on the Pro head, we can get 2 degree more pitch on either side.

2)My Custom lazer text for the Heli.  8)

anwar

Did not have any issues with the feathering shaft for me.  I always tighten them together from both sides with everything in place, and check for both horizontal play (should be close to none) and vertical play (you may get a couple of degrees because of the rubber dampers, that is how they should work).

Widening the motor mount holes is a common problem.  Had to do it with the Scorpion motors on the Align originals too.  Can't remember if I had to do it on the HK TT Pro.

My feather-shaft also had hex screws, it was the see-saw arms that had the non-hex.

For the original Align ones, the Pro and V2 differ in how wide the horizontal portion of the head is, which reduces slop (especially after the dampers weaken a bit).  There was a change in the damper material also, from what I can remember.  The extra pitch range also helps, if you are that kind of flier.



Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

vinay

Not only with the PRO even with the MT, I had to change the collar size so that the bearings dont click. But in the pro tt changing the collars also did not help.

Check the 4th post here

http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1125617&page=190

vinay

I will fix the esc where u have placed, its really big though. Hope it does not alter the CG at 65 Grams weight.

I have put the RX inside the heli. If I have to unplug something then I have to remove the tailservo mount  :banghead:

But I really dont want to mount the RX on the outside as a crash may destroy it. :headscratch: Planning to put 2 servo extensions for programming the quark/ice in case required.

Learnt governor mode. Just realized that there was some thing other than plush and plush was not everything  ;D.

Set the heli at governor mode using Set RPM mode.

Normal: 0 throttle to initialize ESC
Hold: Enabled auto rotation at bail out speed of 14
Mode 1: 2500 RPM - to take off, normal flying.
Mode 2: 2800 RPM - 3D - If i can do something   ;D

The super soft start mode is amazing. At value of 1, it takes 40 seconds to spool up, lol. All the above things set with holding motor in hand.

vinay

One can experience what all Castle ESC offers. Download the following software.

http://www.castlecreations.com/downloads.html

Start it. On one of the tabs, select castle ICE series and select demo mode.

vinay

I have a doubt.

People speak about crazy head speeds of 3600 rpm and all. But thats at 0 pitch and any speeds at 0 pitch absolutely makes no difference!

But what I have noted is that even the mighty motor like a turnigy 2836 3700 (AFAIK the second most powerfull motor next to one of the scorpains) boggs down to 2600 rpm at 12T pinion and -12 degree static test.

So my question would be how would a head speed of 3600 RPM help? Does it gain more momemtum at 0 degree and deliver the energy at -12? Is that why people love crazy head speeds?

Also I have noted one thing, that is:

on a turnigy 2215 motor. on 11 T pinion it gives 2550 rpm at -8 degree static test consuming 21 amp and on 12 T pinion it gave 2450 RPM at -8 degree consuming 27 to 28 Amps. So my observation is quite opposite to why people like crazy head speed.   :headscratch:

anwar

Hmm, your head-speed went down with the bigger pinion ? :headscratch:

Head speed bleeds off with higher pitch, that is a basic fact.  That is why you never stay at extreme pitch ranges for too long, you use them to do "popping" stops ! Every time you do a pitch pump, you bleed off some head-speed, and if you start off with higher speeds, you do not bleed off as much, allowing you to do certain maneuvers much better.  For example, the number of tic-tocs you can do in a given amount of time is directly proportional to the head-speed.  That is why people like higher head-speeds.
Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

vinay

I haven't done tic tocs, so I dont know, but from my experiance, I saw an amazing climb rate and low power consumption with a smaller pinion. So should I go for a smaller or a bigger pinion?

vinay

OK, I will try flying the 450 v2(12t at 100 percent flat TC)  and pro(2800 Governor mode) side by side, see which one feels right.

anwar

Quote from: vinay on December 18, 2010, 05:32:46 PM
I haven't done tic tocs, so I dont know, but from my experiance, I saw an amazing climb rate and low power consumption with a smaller pinion. So should I go for a smaller or a bigger pinion?

You want the following...

1.  Best head-speed

2.  But it should be safe for your blade and blade grips

3.  Higher head-speeds reduces flight duration

Optimize for (or take into consideration) all 3 above factors, and that is what you want !
Hangar : Please see my introduction.
RC India forum and me : About this forum.

vinay

I have spent 2.5 hrs looking for a place to mount the ESC  :banghead: . Its too big to sit under the batt tray. So side is the only obvious option.

Looks like U have put a black zip tie exactly where the motor is on the ESC. How did u manage? Any closeup photo?