Which one is better Carbonite or metal Gear

Started by abhay, January 23, 2011, 07:43:27 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

abhay

Hello friends,
                  I need to buy servos,and came across basically three types i.e.Nylon gear, carbonite gear, metal gear.
I want to use them for my first Engined model whose flying weight will not exceed 1.25 kg.

Im confused whether carbonite or metal gear? I think they are long lasting than nylon ones..
I can take off and fly well. Its landing which sucks :banghead::banghead:

ved

My Suggestion is to go for metal gear servos.
Turnigy 9x w. Er9x | Custom Hovercraft |Scratch Build Boat | Tricopter | Skysurfer V3|

prateek13

depends also on your budget
how many needed and which brand
Award | OFNA Nexx8 | Art-Tech Edge 540T | Glidiator V2 | Hawker Tempest | Cessna Citation Jet
Turnigy 9X
FPV Platforms : CF Tricopter| HK EPP FPV | Bixler 1 | Bixler 2 | DJI Phantom 2 +H3 3D

saikat

buy simple nylon geared ones - they are well up to the job.

its true that metal ones are better but you do not need
them for your model.

I fly .40 size models with standard nylon geared servos.


vinay


sujju

nylon are cheap but they stip easily for stress but gears can be changed easily at not much cost.. metal are expensive but dont strip often but if they do then most of the time you just throw away the servo..
CEO
RcBazaar

atul_pg


Ajay JM

Awaiting the next tornado to fly my kites..

KALYANPRODHAN

The failures goes in two moving parts.
1. Gear and
2. Pot inside for position feedback.

Let Analize financially.
Servo A
======
Lifetime = 100 flight, Cost = X,  .: Cost/Flight = X/100

Servo B
======
Lifetime = 10 flight, Cost = Y, .: Cost/Flight = Y/10

Now compaire between X/100 with Y/10 and take your decision.
Please note the costs are inclusive of postage and other costs.

This is only a economist's view only. Several factor have not been considered like changing servos, Failure of servo and loss/Damage of model due to servo failure etc.

However, I would second Saikatda. Use Nylon Servos. They are cost effective not only in short term but long term too taking replacement as required.
We have to unite and to prove ourself to make indigenous products as well as marketing / Canvasing them. I'm sure we must achieve success if we try unitedly.

sushil_anand

It would have to be a really cheap servo to last only 10 flights.

But I am totally with Saikat and Vinay. Nylon gears are more than good enough for your present requirement. Just don't compromise too much on price.
Hangar: Zlin 50L -120, CMPro Super Chipmunk, Ultimate Bipe EP, Imagine 50, Christen Eagle 160, Ultra Stick, Super Sports Senior

vivek.sharma

Hello All,
In my opinion the nylon gears are too good for this size of model as with this size (i am flying for more then 13 years) none of my nylon gear chipped unless it is a good crash.

For more safety you can go for Karbonite gears as they are said to be 4 times stronger than nylon ones.

The main thing that I recommend is to go with a branded servo like FUTABA, HITEC or JR. as with these I have never seen any unusual servo faliure or behavior, while experinced the same with some chinese brands.

clayboy

nylon or karbonite gears for less slope. metal if u need something that will not strip
henseleit TDR v-bar5,1
henseleit mp xl-e v-bar 4,0
logo 600 v-bar 5,1
logo 400 v-bar 5,1
rave 450 mini v-bar 5,1

asupan

When you are starting new in the hobby get the normal nylon gear servos as they are cheap and you can replace them if required.

Metal geared are a must when there is a you use petrol engines as they are a must for the vibration and the high torque requriements for a larger plane.

Carbonite is a good trade off if you are flying expensive planes and are not big but expensive.